What Happened to William Frawley, Fred Mertz?
A Burlington Boy Who Ran Away to Vaudeville
William Clement Frawley was born on February 26, 1887, in Burlington, Iowa, and he grew up wanting to perform, leaving home young to work the vaudeville circuit, where he learned the trade that would carry him for the next sixty years: how to get a laugh, how to hold a stage, and how to make a living out of being funny. He formed a vaudeville act called Frawley and Louise with his wife, Edna Louise Broedt, whom he married in 1914, and the two of them toured together, singing and joking their way through the small-time circuits, in an era when vaudeville was still the main road into show business. The marriage ended in divorce in 1927, and Frawley never remarried, but the act, and the years on the road, had made him into the kind of performer Hollywood needed when the movies began to talk: a man with a voice, a timing, and a face that could be funny without saying a word.
By the time he reached Hollywood, Frawley was already a veteran, and he settled into the life of a character actor, appearing in more than a hundred films, in small roles that he made memorable, as cops and bartenders and landlords and gruff uncles, the kind of parts that never won awards but that every picture needed. He played a political advisor in Miracle on 34th Street in 1947, one of the most beloved Christmas films ever made, and he worked steadily through the 1940s, in westerns and comedies and dramas, always reliable, always on time, always funny in the way that only a vaudeville man can be funny, with a grumble and a glare that audiences loved. He was, by 1951, 64 years old, and about to get the role that would make him famous to the whole country.
Fred Mertz, 1951 to 1957
I Love Lucy premiered on CBS in 1951, and Frawley played Fred Mertz, the gruff, tight-fisted landlord of the Ricardos apartment building, the husband of Ethel Mertz, played by Vivian Vance, a man who complained about money, who grumbled about his tenants, and who was, underneath it all, one of the warmest characters on the show. Fred and Ethel were the Ricardos' best friends and worst enablers, the couple who went along with every scheme and paid for half of them, and Frawley played him with a vaudeville comic timing that made every grumble land, every eye-roll count, and every line funnier than it had any right to be. He was 64 when the show began, the oldest member of the cast by a wide margin, and he brought to the part the authority of a man who had been funny for a living since before television existed.
The show ran for six seasons, from 1951 to 1957, and it made Frawley famous in a way that a hundred films never had, and it earned him five Emmy nominations, for Outstanding Supporting Actor, without ever bringing him a win, a record that has become part of his legend: the great character actor who was nominated five times and never took home the prize. Sources disagree on the exact ceremony years of those nominations, so this article does not pin them down, but the count itself is not in dispute, and neither is the reason: Frawley was playing a supporting role on the most popular show in America, and the Emmys, in those days, rarely rewarded the man who played the landlord. He did not seem to mind, and he kept working, and when I Love Lucy ended, he was 70, and he was about to get a second sitcom, and a second famous role, almost immediately.
Bub O'Casey and My Three Sons
In 1960 Frawley joined the cast of My Three Sons as Bub O'Casey, the cheerful, slightly disreputable grandfather who moved in with his widowed son-in-law Steve Douglas and his three boys, a character who was, in many ways, Fred Mertz with a softer heart, and who became, over five seasons, one of the most beloved figures on television. Bub was the man who cooked, who told stories, who got into trouble and got out of it with a grin, and Frawley played him with the same warmth he had brought to Fred Mertz, but with less grumbling and more affection, because Bub was a grandfather, not a landlord, and the audience could see, in every scene, how much Frawley enjoyed the part. He was, by some accounts, originally slated to be the lead of the series before Fred MacMurray was cast as Steve Douglas, a what-if that says a great deal about how highly the producers thought of him, even at 73.
He played Bub from 1960 to 1965, and then he was gone, dropped from the show after the studio could no longer obtain insurance on him, because his health, and his heart, had become a risk the producers were no longer willing to carry. It was a cold, businesslike end to a five-year run, and Frawley, who was 78, did not complain publicly, and he took one more job, his final role, playing a horse trainer on an episode of The Lucy Show in October 1965, working once more with Lucille Ball, the woman who had made him famous fourteen years earlier. It was a small part, a farewell of sorts, and it was the last time audiences would see him on screen, although nobody knew it at the time, least of all Frawley himself, who was still, by every account, planning to keep working.
Five Emmy Nominations, No Wins
Frawley's five Emmy nominations, and his failure to win any of them, have become the most quoted fact about his career, and they deserve a closer look, because they say something about the way television treated its character actors in the 1950s. He was nominated for his work as Fred Mertz, in an era when the Emmys were still figuring out what television was, and when supporting actors were an afterthought, and he lost, five times, to men whose names are mostly forgotten now, while his own performance is still watched, in reruns, by millions of people every year. The nominations themselves were the honor, and the fact that he never won has, if anything, made him more famous, not less, because it fits the character he played: the gruff man who never got the credit he deserved, and who kept showing up anyway.
The industry caught up with him eventually. In 2012, forty-six years after his death, Frawley was inducted into the Television Hall of Fame, a recognition that came too late for him to enjoy, but that put his name where it belonged, alongside the other greats of the medium, and that confirmed what the reruns had been saying all along: that Fred Mertz was one of the great comic creations of early television, and that the man who played him was one of the great comic actors of his generation. The Hall of Fame induction was, in its way, the Emmy he never won, and it was given for the same reason the nominations had been given: because he was, quite simply, that good, and because everybody in the business knew it, even if the trophies never quite caught up.
One Marriage, No Children
Frawley was married once, to Edna Louise Broedt, from 1914 to 1927, and the marriage, which had begun as a vaudeville partnership, ended in divorce, and he never married again, and he had no children. He lived, for most of his Hollywood years, as a bachelor, a man whose family was, by all accounts, the people he worked with, and the friends he made on sets, and the cast of I Love Lucy, who became, over six seasons, something like a second family, with Lucille Ball and Desi Arnaz at its head. Arnaz, in particular, was fond of him, and protective of him, and it was Arnaz who had fought to cast him as Fred Mertz in the first place, over the objections of executives who thought he was too old, and too difficult, and too much of a drinker, and Arnaz who stood by him when the show needed him most.
When Frawley died, his estate was valued at $92,446, a modest sum for a man who had worked for sixty years, but he had also made a deal, late in his career, that would outlive him: a residuals agreement that paid his heirs in perpetuity, a rare arrangement for a character actor of his era, and one that said a great deal about how much his work was worth, even when the industry would not say so with an Emmy. Arnaz's memoir says Frawley had lost his driver's license, a detail that hints at the drinking that had dogged him for years, and that the executives had worried about, and that he had, by most accounts, kept under control on set, where he was, by every account, a professional, who arrived on time, knew his lines, and made the day easier for everyone around him.
A Heart Attack on Hollywood Boulevard
On March 3, 1966, Frawley went to see a movie on Hollywood Boulevard, and on his way home he collapsed on the sidewalk, of a heart attack, and he was taken to Hollywood Receiving Hospital, where he was pronounced dead. He was 79. The news traveled quickly through the business, and the tributes came from the people who had known him best, led by Desi Arnaz, who took out a full-page advertisement in the trade papers that read, simply, Buenas noches, amigo, good night, friend, a farewell that has become one of the most famous obituaries in Hollywood history, because it was, in its way, the perfect tribute to a man who had been, above all, a friend, and a professional, and a comic.
His pallbearers were Arnaz, Fred MacMurray, and Don Fedderson, the producer of My Three Sons, three men who had, between them, given him his two great television roles, and who carried him to his burial at San Fernando Mission Cemetery, in Mission Hills, California, where he was laid to rest after a life that had run from Burlington, Iowa, to vaudeville, to a hundred films, to two of the most famous sitcoms in history. He had no children to mourn him, and no widow, but he had something rarer: a cast, and a crew, and an audience, who remembered him, and who still do, every time Fred Mertz grumbles about the rent, or Bub O'Casey tells a story, in reruns that have never really stopped.
What Happened to William Frawley, in the End
So what happened to William Frawley? He became Fred Mertz, he became Bub O'Casey, he was nominated for five Emmys and never won one, and he died on March 3, 1966, on Hollywood Boulevard, of a heart attack, at 79, after a movie, on his way home, which is, for a man who had spent sixty years in show business, about as ordinary an ending as anyone could ask for, and about as fitting: he died in Hollywood, on the street where he had worked, doing what he had always done, which was going to the pictures. He left no children, and a modest estate, and a residuals deal that paid his heirs in perpetuity, and a full-page farewell from Desi Arnaz that said, in three words, what the Emmys never had: good night, friend.
What remains is Fred Mertz, still grumbling in reruns, still tight with a dollar, still the landlord every viewer recognizes, and Bub O'Casey, still telling stories to three boys who are, by now, grandfathers themselves, and the five Emmy nominations, still un-won, and the Hall of Fame plaque, still hanging, forty-six years late, and the example of a vaudeville man who started in Burlington, Iowa, in 1887, and ended in Hollywood, in 1966, having done exactly what he set out to do: make people laugh, for sixty years, without ever stopping, and without ever needing to be the star.
Frequently asked questions
What happened to William Frawley?
William Frawley died on March 3, 1966, in Hollywood, California, at 79, of a heart attack, after collapsing on Hollywood Boulevard following a movie. He was pronounced dead at Hollywood Receiving Hospital. He had played Fred Mertz on I Love Lucy and Bub O'Casey on My Three Sons.
Who did William Frawley play on I Love Lucy?
Fred Mertz, the gruff, tight-fisted landlord of the Ricardos apartment building, and the husband of Ethel Mertz, played by Vivian Vance. He played the role from 1951 to 1957.
How many Emmys did William Frawley win?
None. He was nominated five times for his work as Fred Mertz and never won. Sources disagree on the exact ceremony years of the nominations. He was inducted into the Television Hall of Fame in 2012, forty-six years after his death.
Was William Frawley married?
Once, to Edna Louise Broedt, from 1914 to 1927. They had performed together in vaudeville as Frawley and Louise. He never remarried, and he had no children.
Why did William Frawley leave My Three Sons?
He was dropped from the show after the 1965 season because the studio could no longer obtain insurance on him, due to his health and his heart. One profile claims he suffered a stroke in the fall of 1964, but that is single-source and unconfirmed.
What was William Frawley's last role?
A horse trainer on an episode of The Lucy Show in October 1965, working once more with Lucille Ball. It was his final screen appearance.
How did William Frawley die?
Of a heart attack. He collapsed on Hollywood Boulevard on March 3, 1966, after seeing a movie, and was pronounced dead at Hollywood Receiving Hospital. He was 79.
How old was William Frawley when he died?
Seventy-nine. He was born February 26, 1887, in Burlington, Iowa, and died March 3, 1966, in Hollywood, California.
Sources
- EN WikipediaBirth, vaudeville, Fred Mertz, Bub O'Casey, five Emmy nominations, death
- IMDbBirth February 26, 1887, death March 3, 1966, Fred Mertz and Bub O'Casey roles
- The Retro TubeFive Emmy nominations, estate, residuals deal, Arnaz farewell, pallbearers