$ CelebPaid
Where Are They Now

What Happened to Lionel Barrymore, Mr. Potter?

Lionel Barrymore in a portrait
Lionel Barrymore in a studio portrait. He won the Best Actor Oscar for A Free Soul in 1931 and died of a heart attack in 1954 at 76.Wikimedia Commons, public domain, SAYRE studio portrait
The short answer: Lionel Barrymore (born Lionel Herbert Blythe, April 28, 1878, in Philadelphia) died November 15, 1954, at 76, of a heart attack, at Valley Hospital in Van Nuys, California. He was the Oscar-winning actor of A Free Soul (1931), the brother of Ethel and John Barrymore, and the man modern audiences know as Mr. Potter in It's a Wonderful Life (1946). He spent his final years in a wheelchair after hip injuries and arthritis, and he was married twice and never remarried after his second wife died in 1936.

The Eldest of the Barrymores

Lionel Barrymore was born Lionel Herbert Blythe on April 28, 1878, in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, the eldest of the three children of Maurice Barrymore and Georgie Drew, and he was born into acting the way other children are born into farming or shopkeeping, because his father was a celebrated stage actor and his mother came from the Drew family of actors, and his younger siblings, Ethel and John, would both become famous in their own right, and the three of them, in the end, became the most famous acting family America ever produced, and Lionel, the eldest, was the one who stayed longest, and worked hardest, and outlived them both. One low-tier source gives his birth date as April 12, 1878, and this article follows the current record, which gives April 28, and notes the variant honestly rather than pretending the record is settled.

He grew up backstage and on the road, and he learned the stage the way other boys learned a trade, and he did not, at first, want to be an actor at all, because he wanted to be a painter, and he studied art in Paris, and he worked as an artist and an etcher, and he was good at it, and he might have stayed an artist if the stage had not kept calling him back, and in the end the stage won, and he became, first, a stage actor of real distinction, and then, when the movies came, a film actor, and then a director, and then a radio star, and he did it all, in the end, with the same serious, craftsmanlike care he had once given to his drawings, and the family name, in the end, became his, and his brother's, and his sister's, all at once.

From the Stage to an Oscar

Barrymore came to Hollywood in the 1920s, after a long career on the stage, and he found, in the new medium of talking pictures, a second career, and he became one of the most respected character actors in the business, and in 1929 he was nominated for an Academy Award as a director for Madame X, and in 1931 he won the Academy Award for Best Actor for A Free Soul, playing an alcoholic lawyer who defends his daughter's fiance in a murder trial, and the win made history, because he and his sister Ethel, who had won her own Oscar, became the first brother and sister ever to win Academy Awards, and the honour, in the end, belonged to the whole family, and to the stage tradition they had come from, and to the idea that acting was a craft, and a calling, and not just a way of being famous.

He worked steadily through the 1930s, in Grand Hotel in 1932, and in Dinner at Eight in 1933, and in David Copperfield in 1935, and in dozens of other pictures, and he was, by then, one of the most familiar faces in Hollywood, and one of the most trusted, and directors knew they could give him anything, a judge, or a doctor, or a villain, or a saint, and he would make it real, and he did it, in the end, for more than sixty years, from his first stage appearance as a boy to his last film in 1953, and the career, in the end, was one of the longest in the history of American acting, and one of the most honoured, and one of the least showy, because Barrymore never chased the spotlight, and the spotlight, in the end, came to him anyway.

Mr. Potter and the Capra Years

Barrymore's most famous role came late, in 1946, when Frank Capra cast him as Henry F. Potter, the miserly banker of Bedford Falls, in It's a Wonderful Life, and the film, which was a modest success on release, became, in the end, one of the most beloved films ever made, and Potter became, in the end, the definitive screen miser, the man in the wheelchair who owns the town and tries to own George Bailey too, and Barrymore played him, in the end, from his own wheelchair, and with a bitterness that was entirely convincing, and the role, in the end, outlived him, and outlived Capra, and became a piece of Christmas itself, and every December, millions of people meet Lionel Barrymore again, as Mr. Potter, and remember him, and the film, in the end, is his monument.

He had played a very different kind of patriarch eight years earlier, as Grandpa Vanderhof in Capra's You Can't Take It With You in 1938, the gentle, eccentric head of the Sycamore family, and the two roles, taken together, show the range of the man, because Vanderhof is warm, and funny, and free, and Potter is cold, and grasping, and cruel, and Barrymore played both of them, in the end, with the same conviction, and the same craft, and the same deep, gravelly voice, and the Capra films, in the end, are the reason modern audiences know him at all, because the rest of his work, the dozens of films, and the stage career, and the radio work, has faded, and the two Capra pictures, in the end, have not.

The Wheelchair Years

In 1936 a drawing table fell on Barrymore and broke his hip, and he recovered, and then he broke the hip again, and the second break, and the arthritis that came with it, confined him, in the end, to a wheelchair, and after 1937 and 1938 he spent most of his time in the chair, and he could stand briefly, most notably at his brother John's funeral in 1942, but walking was gone for good, and the wheelchair became, in the end, a part of who he was, on screen and off, and directors wrote it into his parts, and audiences accepted it, and Barrymore, in the end, never complained about it in public, and never let it stop him working, and he kept acting, in the end, for seventeen more years, in the chair, and from the chair, and the work, in the end, never suffered, and neither did the man.

He also became, in those years, a familiar voice on the radio, playing Ebenezer Scrooge in A Christmas Carol every year, and the broadcasts, in the end, became a holiday tradition of their own, and his Scrooge, like his Potter, was a miser with a heart, and the voice, in the end, was the same deep, warm, unmistakable voice that had carried him through sixty years on stage and screen, and the radio work, in the end, was a gift to a man who could no longer walk to a set, because he could sit, and speak, and be heard, and the audience, in the end, never saw the chair, and only heard the voice, and the voice, in the end, was enough.

Two Marriages and a Quiet Heart

Barrymore was married twice. His first wife was the actress Doris Rankin, whom he married in 1905, and with whom he had two children, both of whom died in infancy, and the marriage, in the end, did not survive the grief, and they divorced in 1923, and in the same year he married his second wife, the actress Irene Fenwick, and the marriage lasted thirteen years, until she died on December 24, 1936, of complications from what was then called overdieting, and she was 49, and Barrymore, in the end, never remarried, and he lived the last eighteen years of his life alone, in the house of a friend, Mrs. J. E. Wheeler, and with her two daughters, and he was, in the end, a widower for longer than he had been a husband, and the Christmas Eve on which Irene died, in the end, stayed with him, and he never spoke of it lightly, and never tried to replace her.

His brother John died in 1942, and his sister Ethel survived him, and the family, in the end, was a small one, and a sad one, and a famous one, and Lionel, the eldest, was the one who held it together, and the one who kept working, and the one who kept the name alive, and the children he had lost, and the wife he had lost, and the brother he had lost, were, in the end, a part of the story, and a part of the man, and the work, in the end, was the thing that carried him through, and the work, in the end, was the thing he gave his life to, and the life, in the end, was the work, and the work was the life.

The Reported Tax Trouble

In the last fifteen years of his life Barrymore had serious trouble with the Internal Revenue Service over back taxes, and the trouble is reported in secondary sources, and it is reported, not proved in court, and this article says so plainly, because the distinction matters, and the reports say that from 1939 he had to pay most of his earnings in back taxes, and that Louis B. Mayer had to make an arrangement with the IRS to deduct money from his pay, and that even after his death the IRS seized the proceeds from the sale of his artwork, and the story, in the end, is a sad one, because a man who had worked for sixty years, and earned a great deal, and given a great deal, ended his life owing money to the government, and the money, in the end, was the least interesting thing about him, and the work, in the end, was the most interesting, and the work, in the end, is what survived.

He was, by then, an old man in a wheelchair, living in someone else's house, and working when he could, and the tax trouble, in the end, was one more burden, and one more reason to keep working, and he did keep working, and he did it, in the end, with the same professionalism he had always shown, and the studios, in the end, kept hiring him, because he was Lionel Barrymore, and because he was reliable, and because he was good, and the IRS, in the end, was a footnote, and the films, in the end, were the story, and the story, in the end, is the one this article tells, and the tax trouble, in the end, is a part of it, and only a part, and it is reported here as reported, and not as a court finding, because that is what the record supports.

What Happened to Lionel Barrymore, in the End

So what happened to Lionel Barrymore? He was born Lionel Herbert Blythe in Philadelphia in 1878, he was the eldest of Maurice Barrymore and Georgie Drew's three children, he studied art in Paris and came to the stage, he was nominated as a director for Madame X in 1929, he won the Best Actor Oscar for A Free Soul in 1931, he played Mr. Potter in It's a Wonderful Life in 1946, he broke his hip in 1936 and spent his last seventeen years in a wheelchair, he married Doris Rankin in 1905 and divorced her in 1923, he married Irene Fenwick in 1923 and lost her on Christmas Eve in 1936, he played Scrooge on the radio every Christmas, he gave his last performance in Main Street to Broadway in 1953, alongside his sister Ethel, and he died on November 15, 1954, at 76, of a heart attack, at Valley Hospital in Van Nuys, California.

He was entombed beside his wife Irene Fenwick and his brother John at Calvary Cemetery in Hollywood, and he is, still, the voice of Scrooge, and the face of Mr. Potter, and the winner of the Best Actor Oscar for A Free Soul, and the first brother, with Ethel, to win Academy Awards, and the man with two stars on the Hollywood Walk of Fame, and the elder statesman of the Barrymore family, and the actor who worked for more than sixty years, and who did it, in the end, in a wheelchair, and who died, in the end, at seventy-six, of a heart attack, in Van Nuys, and who is, in the end, remembered every Christmas, as the miser who tried to own Bedford Falls, and as the man who, in the end, could not.

Frequently asked questions

What happened to Lionel Barrymore?

Lionel Barrymore died on November 15, 1954, at 76, of a heart attack, at Valley Hospital in Van Nuys, California. He was entombed beside his second wife, Irene Fenwick, and his brother John at Calvary Cemetery in Hollywood.

When and where was Lionel Barrymore born?

April 28, 1878, in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, as Lionel Herbert Blythe. He was the eldest of the three children of Maurice Barrymore and Georgie Drew. One low-tier source gives April 12, 1878; this article follows the current record, which gives April 28.

What was Lionel Barrymore's most famous role?

Henry F. Potter, the miserly banker in Frank Capra's It's a Wonderful Life (1946). He also played Grandpa Vanderhof in Capra's You Can't Take It With You (1938), and he played Ebenezer Scrooge on the radio every Christmas.

Did Lionel Barrymore win an Oscar?

Yes. He won the Academy Award for Best Actor for A Free Soul (1931). He was also nominated as a director for Madame X (1929). He and his sister Ethel were the first brother and sister ever to win Academy Awards.

Why was Lionel Barrymore in a wheelchair?

A drawing table fell on him in 1936 and broke his hip. A second break followed, and arthritis set in. After 1937 and 1938 he spent most of his time in a wheelchair, but he kept acting for another 17 years, and directors wrote the chair into his parts.

Who was Lionel Barrymore married to?

Twice. Doris Rankin, from 1905 until their divorce in 1923; their two children died in infancy. Irene Fenwick, from 1923 until her death on December 24, 1936. He never remarried.

What happened to Lionel Barrymore's taxes?

Secondary sources report that he owed large sums in back taxes to the IRS in his last 15 years, and that from 1939 most of his earnings went to back taxes. This is reported, not a court finding, and this article says so plainly.

What was Lionel Barrymore's last film?

Main Street to Broadway (1953), in which he appeared alongside his sister Ethel. He died a year later, on November 15, 1954, at 76.

Sources

  • EN WikipediaBirth, Barrymore family, A Free Soul Oscar, Madame X nomination, wheelchair, marriages, death
  • Reel ClassicsNew York Times obituary 1954, Valley Hospital Van Nuys, heart ailment, Scrooge on radio
  • Hollywood's Golden AgeA Free Soul, It's a Wonderful Life, wheelchair, IRS back taxes, death November 15 1954