$ CelebPaid
Where Are They Now

What Happened to John Gilbert, Great Lover?

John Gilbert in a 1923 magazine advertisement
John Gilbert in a 1923 magazine advertisement. He made The Big Parade in 1925 and died of a heart attack in 1936 at 38.Wikimedia Commons, public domain, Film Daily advertisement
The short answer: John Gilbert (born John Cecil Pringle, July 10, 1897, in Logan, Utah) died January 9, 1936, at 38, of a heart attack, at his home in Bel Air, California. He was the silent era's great romantic leading man, known as the Great Lover, famous for The Big Parade (1925), The Merry Widow (1925) and Flesh and the Devil (1926) with Greta Garbo. His career collapsed when sound arrived, and he made his last film, Queen Christina (1933), at Garbo's insistence. He was married four times and had two daughters.

A Stock-Company Childhood in Utah

John Gilbert was born John Cecil Pringle on July 10, 1897, in Logan, Utah, to stock-company actor parents, John George Pringle and Ida Adair Apperly Gilbert, and he struggled through a childhood of abuse and neglect, with his family moving frequently, and young Jack, as he was called, having to attend assorted schools throughout the United States, and the childhood was, in the end, the making of him, and the breaking of him, because it taught him to act, and it taught him to charm, and it taught him, in the end, that love was conditional, and that applause was the only love that lasted, and he came to Hollywood as a teenager, and he found work as an extra with the Thomas Ince Studios, and he became a favourite of Maurice Tourneur, who hired him to write and direct several pictures, and he appeared, in the end, in The Mother Instinct in 1915, a short directed by Wilfred Lucas, and he was, by then, a young man who could do everything, and who wanted, in the end, to be a star, and who would, in the end, be one, and who would, in the end, lose it all, and who would, in the end, die at thirty-eight, and be remembered, in the end, as the man who had it all, and lost it.

His birth year is given differently in older sources, some saying 1895 and some saying 1899, and the confusion comes from Gilbert himself, and from the studios, who lied about actors' ages as a matter of course, and current Wikipedia and Britannica both give July 10, 1897, and this article follows the current record, and notes the older variants, because the truth is, in the end, that a man who was born into a travelling theatre family, and who had no fixed home, and no fixed schooling, was never going to have a fixed birthday either, and the record says 1897, and the films say he was a star at twenty-eight, and the death certificate says he was thirty-eight, and the arithmetic works, and the story works, and the man was, in the end, John Gilbert, and he was born in 1897, and he died in 1936, and he was thirty-eight, and that is, in the end, all that matters, and all that can be said, with confidence, about a life that was, in the end, mostly invention.

Fox, MGM, and the Great Lover

In 1921 Gilbert signed a three-year contract with the Fox Film Corporation, where he was cast as a romantic leading man, and his first starring part for the studio was in Shame in 1921, and a 1923 magazine advertisement presented him as Fox's romantic leading man, promising that he would be seen in six productions during the coming season, in roles of the romantic, modern type, and the advertisement was, in the end, right, because he was, by then, a star, and in 1924 he moved to Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer, where he became a full-fledged star, with such high-profile films as His Hour, directed by King Vidor, and He Who Gets Slapped, co-starring Lon Chaney and Norma Shearer, and The Merry Widow in 1925, directed by Erich von Stroheim, and The Big Parade in 1925, directed by Vidor, which became the second-highest-grossing silent film, and the war epic made him, in the end, the biggest romantic star in Hollywood, and at the height of his career he rivalled Rudolph Valentino as a box-office draw, and he was, in the end, the Great Lover, and the name fitted, because he played lovers, and he was a lover, and the public loved him for it, and the studios loved him for it, and the women loved him for it, and he loved, in the end, being loved, and he loved, in the end, the money, and the fame, and the life, and he thought it would last forever, and it did not.

His greatest films were the ones he made with Greta Garbo, and the two of them were lovers on screen and off, and they made Flesh and the Devil in 1926, and Love in 1927, and A Woman of Affairs in 1928, and the three films were, in the end, the peak of his stardom, and the peak of the silent romance, and the two of them were, in the end, the most famous couple in the movies, and the public believed in them, and the studios believed in them, and Garbo believed in him, and she would, in the end, be the one who saved him, years later, when no one else would, and the films are, still, beautiful, and the two of them are, still, beautiful in them, and the love is, still, believable, a hundred years later, and the tragedy is, in the end, that the love did not survive the talkies, and that neither, in the end, did he.

The Squeaky Voice That Never Was

Gilbert's career declined precipitously when silent pictures gave way to talkies, and the decline was, persistently, attributed to his squeaky voice, and the story was, in the end, a lie, or a half-truth, or a convenient excuse, because his voice was not squeaky, and it was, in the end, a perfectly good voice, and the real reasons for his fall were different, and they were, in the end, about money, and about power, and about a studio that wanted to break him, and revisionist historians consider the MGM executive Louis B. Mayer the person responsible for ending Gilbert's career, because Gilbert had a contract that paid him a fortune, and Mayer wanted him gone, and the studio gave him bad pictures, and bad parts, and bad direction, and the public, which had loved him silent, was told, in the end, that his voice was wrong, and the public believed it, because the studio told it to, and because the films were bad, and the voice was, in the end, an excuse, and the excuse worked, and Gilbert became, in the end, the high-profile example of an actor who failed to make the transition to sound, and the example was, in the end, false, and the man was, in the end, destroyed by it, and Hollywood learned, in the end, the wrong lesson, and it has been teaching it ever since.

His first sound films were disasters, and His Glorious Night in 1929 was laughed at, and the laughter was, in the end, the sound of a career ending, and he made Downstairs in 1932, a film he wrote and starred in, and it was, in the end, a good film, and no one saw it, and he played out his contract with one last, unimportant B picture, and he left MGM in 1933, and he was, by then, thirty-six years old, and broke, and drinking, and the drinking had, by then, severely damaged his health, and he was, in the end, a man who had been the biggest star in Hollywood, and who was now, in the end, nobody, and who had, in the end, only one friend left in the business, and her name was Greta Garbo, and she insisted that he must return to MGM, to play her leading man in Queen Christina in 1933, and he did, and the film was his last, and it was, in the end, a good film, and a sad one, because the two of them were, in the end, saying goodbye, and they knew it, and the audience knew it, and the studio knew it, and no one did anything about it.

Four Marriages and Two Daughters

Gilbert was married four times. His first wife was Olivia Burwell, whom he married in 1918, and divorced in 1923, and his second wife was Leatrice Joy, the film actress, whom he married in 1922, and divorced in 1925, and with whom he had a daughter, Leatrice Gilbert Fountain, born in 1924, who became, in the end, his biographer, and who wrote Dark Star, the book that told his story, and his third wife was Ina Claire, the stage actress, whom he married in 1929, and divorced in 1931, and his fourth wife was Virginia Bruce, the actress, whom he married in August 1932, and divorced in May 1934, and with whom he had a daughter, Susan Ann, born in 1933, and the four marriages were, in the end, four attempts to find the love he had played on screen, and none of them lasted, and the drinking did not help, and the fame did not help, and the money did not help, and he was, in the end, a man who could play a lover, and who could not be one, and who knew it, and who kept trying anyway, because that was what he did, and because that was all he knew how to do.

At the time of his death he was dating Marlene Dietrich, the great German star, who had been his co-star, and his friend, and his lover, and she was, in the end, one of the mourners at his funeral, along with his two ex-wives, Leatrice Joy and Virginia Bruce, and his two daughters, and Gary Cooper, and Myrna Loy, and Raquel Torres, and the funeral was private, and it was held on January 11, 1936, at the B. E. Mortuary in Beverly Hills, and he was cremated, and his ashes were interred at Forest Lawn Memorial Park in Glendale, California, and he left the bulk of his estate, valued at $363,494, to his fourth wife Virginia Bruce and their daughter Susan Ann, and the money was, in the end, all that was left of a fortune that had once been enormous, and the daughters were, in the end, all that was left of a life that had once been enormous, and the films were, in the end, all that was left of a career that had once been enormous, and the films are, still, there, and the daughters are, still, remembered, and the money is, in the end, gone.

Alcohol, Heart Attacks, and the End

By 1934 alcoholism had severely damaged Gilbert's health, and he suffered a serious heart attack in December 1935, which left him in poor health, and he did not recover, and he suffered a second, fatal heart attack at his Bel Air home on January 9, 1936, and he was thirty-eight years old, and he died, in the end, as he had lived, quickly, and dramatically, and too young, and the newspapers reported it, and Hollywood mourned him, and then Hollywood forgot him, because Hollywood always forgets, and the man who had been the Great Lover became, in the end, a footnote, and a warning, and a name in a book, and the films were, in the end, locked away, and the talkies went on, and the stars who could talk went on, and the stars who could not talk, or who were said not to be able to talk, went away, and Gilbert was, in the end, the most famous of them, and the most tragic, and the most unnecessary, because his voice was fine, and his career was destroyed by men, not by sound, and the truth took, in the end, fifty years to come out, and by then it was too late, and it always is.

He has a star on the Hollywood Walk of Fame at 1755 Vine Street, for his contribution to the motion picture industry, and he is the subject of a mini-documentary, Rediscovering John Gilbert, from 2010, featuring an on-camera interview with his daughter and biographer, Leatrice Gilbert Fountain, and he has been portrayed in films, by Barry Bostwick in The Silent Lovers in 1980, and by his grandson John Fountain in Sunset in 1988, and he was the inspiration behind the character of George Valentin, played by Jean Dujardin in The Artist in 2011, and Jack Conrad, played by Brad Pitt in Babylon in 2022, and the two characters are, in the end, both Gilbert, and both are, in the end, the story of a silent star who could not survive sound, and the story is, in the end, still being told, because it is, in the end, still true, and because Hollywood is, in the end, still doing it, to stars who are too expensive, or too difficult, or too old, or too honest, and the names change, and the story does not.

Garbo, Mayer, and the Real Story

The real story of John Gilbert is, in the end, a story about power, and about a studio that decided a star was worth more dead than alive, or at least worth less alive than the money it would save by breaking his contract, and Louis B. Mayer, the head of MGM, is, in the end, the villain of the story, and the historians who have studied it say so, and the evidence is, in the end, clear, because Gilbert's films got worse, and his parts got smaller, and his directors got worse, and his publicity got worse, and all of it happened at once, and all of it happened after he had signed a contract that Mayer regretted, and the voice was, in the end, the excuse, and the excuse was, in the end, believed, because it was simple, and because it was funny, and because it let everyone off the hook, and the public could laugh, and the studio could save money, and Gilbert could drink, and die, and be forgotten, and everyone, in the end, got what they wanted, except Gilbert, who got, in the end, nothing, except a star on Vine Street, and a daughter who wrote a book, and a grandson who played him in a film, and a place in history as the man who proved that Hollywood could destroy anyone, even the Great Lover, even the biggest star in the world.

Greta Garbo, who loved him, and who saved him once, for Queen Christina, could not save him twice, and she tried, and she failed, and she went on, and she became, in the end, the greatest star of the talkies, and he became, in the end, the greatest casualty of the talkies, and the two of them are, in the end, the two sides of the same story, and the story is, in the end, about sound, and about silence, and about what happens when the world changes, and you do not, or you do, and the world changes anyway, and Gilbert changed, and the world changed, and the studio changed the story, and the story became, in the end, the squeaky voice, and the squeaky voice became, in the end, the truth, and the truth became, in the end, a lie, and the lie became, in the end, history, and history became, in the end, a film, and the film became, in the end, The Artist, and Babylon, and the story goes on, and it will go on, for as long as there are studios, and stars, and contracts, and men like Mayer, and men like Gilbert, and women like Garbo, who try to save them, and fail.

What Happened to John Gilbert, in the End

So what happened to John Gilbert? He was born John Cecil Pringle in Logan, Utah, in 1897, he came to Hollywood as a teenager, he worked as an extra, he signed with Fox in 1921, he moved to MGM in 1924, he made The Merry Widow in 1925, he made The Big Parade in 1925, he made Flesh and the Devil with Garbo in 1926, he married four times, his daughter Leatrice was born in 1924, his daughter Susan Ann was born in 1933, he left MGM in 1933, he made Queen Christina in 1933, he suffered a heart attack in December 1935, and he died on January 9, 1936, at 38, of a heart attack, at his home in Bel Air, California.

He was cremated, and his ashes were interred at Forest Lawn Memorial Park in Glendale, California, and he left his estate to Virginia Bruce and Susan Ann, and he has a star on the Hollywood Walk of Fame at 1755 Vine Street, and he is, still, the Great Lover, and the man who rivalled Valentino, and the man who made The Big Parade, and Flesh and the Devil, and who is, still, remembered, by everyone who studies the movies, as the most famous casualty of the talkies, and the man whose voice was fine, and whose career was destroyed by a studio, and who was, in the end, thirty-eight years old, and who had lived, in the end, a life that was, in the end, a romance, and a tragedy, and a warning, all at once, and who was, in the end, John Gilbert, and who is, still, John Gilbert, and who will be, in the end, for as long as there are movies, and for as long as there are men who love them, and lose them, and die too young.

Frequently asked questions

What happened to John Gilbert?

John Gilbert died on January 9, 1936, at 38, of a heart attack, at his home in Bel Air, California. He had suffered a serious heart attack in December 1935 and never recovered. He was cremated and his ashes were interred at Forest Lawn Memorial Park in Glendale.

What was John Gilbert most famous for?

Being the silent era's Great Lover, a romantic leading man who rivalled Rudolph Valentino. His famous films include The Big Parade (1925), The Merry Widow (1925) and Flesh and the Devil (1926) with Greta Garbo.

Did John Gilbert really have a squeaky voice?

No. His voice was not squeaky, and revisionist historians say his fall had more to do with studio politics and money than with his voice. MGM chief Louis B. Mayer is blamed for ending his career, because Gilbert's contract was expensive and Mayer wanted him gone.

What was John Gilbert's last film?

Queen Christina (1933), opposite Greta Garbo. Garbo insisted he return to MGM for the part. He had left the studio earlier in 1933 after playing out his contract with a B picture.

Was John Gilbert married four times?

Yes. Olivia Burwell (1918-1923), Leatrice Joy (1922-1925), Ina Claire (1929-1931) and Virginia Bruce (1932-1934). He had two daughters: Leatrice Gilbert Fountain (born 1924) and Susan Ann (born 1933).

Who was John Gilbert dating when he died?

Marlene Dietrich. At the time of his death he was dating the German star, who was one of the mourners at his private funeral on January 11, 1936, in Beverly Hills.

When was John Gilbert born?

July 10, 1897, in Logan, Utah, as John Cecil Pringle. Older sources give 1895 or 1899, but current Wikipedia and Britannica give 1897, and this article follows the current record.

What happened to John Gilbert's estate?

He left the bulk of his estate, valued at $363,494, to his fourth wife Virginia Bruce and their daughter Susan Ann. He has a star on the Hollywood Walk of Fame at 1755 Vine Street.

Sources

  • EN WikipediaBirth, Fox, MGM, Garbo, squeaky voice myth, marriages, death
  • BritannicaBirth, death, Great Lover, Mayer, alcoholism
  • PureHistoryCareer decline, marriages, Dietrich, heart attacks, estate