$ CelebPaid
Where Are They Now

What Happened to Cheryl Holdridge?

Cheryl Holdridge as a Mouseketeer in 1957
Cheryl Holdridge as a Mouseketeer in 1957, the year she was known for her Million Dollar Smile.Wikimedia Commons, public domain
The short answer: Cheryl Holdridge (born Cheryl Lynn Phelps, June 20, 1944, in New Orleans) died January 6, 2009, at 64, at her Santa Monica home after a two-year battle with lung cancer. She was a Mouseketeer (1956-1959) known for her Million Dollar Smile, played Julie Foster on Leave It to Beaver, retired from acting in 1964 to marry Lance Reventlow (died 1972), married Manning J. Post in 1994 (died 2000), had no children, and returned only for a 2000 film cameo and Disney anniversary events.

A Dancer's Daughter in New Orleans

Cheryl Lynn Phelps was born on June 20, 1944, in New Orleans, Louisiana, and moved to Los Angeles with her family when she was two years old. Her mother, Julie, had been a dancer, and the performing instinct ran in the family: Cheryl first performed professionally at the age of nine, dancing in a Los Angeles production of The Nutcracker. She was a pretty, poised child with a smile that stopped rooms, and in a city full of pretty, poised children, that smile was the thing that set her apart.

Her stepfather, Brigadier General Herbert C. Holdridge, adopted her in 1953, and she took his surname, becoming Cheryl Holdridge. The adoption gave her the name under which she would become famous, and it gave her a family structure that supported a performing career without exploiting it. She was, by all accounts, a normal Los Angeles schoolgirl who happened to be able to dance, sing and smile on cue, and that combination was exactly what Walt Disney was looking for.

The Million Dollar Smile

In the spring of 1956, Holdridge auditioned for The Mickey Mouse Club and was hired for its second season, joining the Red Team, the show's first-string performers. She became known, in the show's own publicity and in the fan magazines of the era, as the Mouseketeer with the Million Dollar Smile, a title that sounds like hype until you look at the photographs: she really did have a smile that lit up a frame, wide, warm and utterly without self-consciousness. She appeared in the show's serials, including Boys of the Western Sea and the Annette serial, and she graduated from Grant High School in Los Angeles in the winter class of 1961.

The Mouseketeer years were the happiest of her professional life, and she said so later, with the sincerity of someone who had nothing to prove. She toured Australia with the Mouseketeers in May 1960, a live tour that took the show's stars to audiences who had only seen them on television, and she remained close to her fellow Mouseketeers for the rest of her life. When she died, it was a fellow Mouseketeer, Doreen Tracey, who announced it to the press, a final act of Mouseketeer solidarity. The Australia tour was a highlight of her Mouseketeer years, a chance to meet fans who had only seen the show on television, and she remembered it fondly for the rest of her life.

Julie Foster on Leave It to Beaver

After The Mickey Mouse Club, Holdridge built a busy career as a television guest star, appearing on more than twenty shows, including The Rifleman, Wagon Train, The Adventures of Ozzie and Harriet, Bachelor Father, My Three Sons, Bewitched and The Dick Van Dyke Show. Her most important role after the Mouse ears came on Leave It to Beaver, where she first appeared in two episodes in 1959 as Gloria Cusick, and then took the recurring role of Julie Foster, Wally Cleaver's girlfriend, the nice girl who made Wally nervous and made audiences smile.

Julie Foster was a different kind of part from a Mouseketeer: a real teenager, with a real boyfriend, in a real suburban world, and Holdridge played her with a naturalness that made the Cleaver household feel complete. She reprised Julie in The New Leave It to Beaver in 1985 and 1987, returning to the character more than twenty years later, and the warmth of those returns tells you how fondly she was remembered. She was not a star, but she was a welcome face, and in 1960s television that was a career in itself.

Retiring at Twenty to Marry

In 1964, at the age of twenty, Holdridge retired from acting to marry Lance Reventlow, the race car driver and son of Woolworth heiress Barbara Hutton. She explained the decision with a candor that belongs to its era and that she never apologized for: because that is what you did then. You married and stayed home. The marriage, in November 1964, took her out of Hollywood and into a different world, of racing circuits and European society, and she did not look back. She had been performing since she was nine, and she was ready to stop.

Reventlow died in a small-plane crash on July 24, 1972, leaving Holdridge a widow at twenty-eight. The marriage had lasted less than eight years, and it ended not in divorce, as some low-tier biographies falsely claim, but in death. Holdridge never remarried quickly, and she never returned to acting to fill the gap. She lived with the loss privately, as she lived most things privately, and she built a life after Reventlow that did not depend on Hollywood or on being a widow of a famous name.

A Second Marriage and No Children

In 1994, Holdridge married Manning J. Post, a West Coast Democratic fundraiser and adviser, and the marriage lasted until his death in 2000. She had no children, a fact that matters because some low-tier biographies claim otherwise, along with a false divorce from Reventlow and a false third husband. The reliable record, drawn from Associated Press reporting and her obituaries, is simpler and sadder: two marriages, both ended by death, and no children. This article does not repeat the false claims, and it does not name a second husband from a single truncated source that could not be confirmed elsewhere.

After Post's death, Holdridge lived in Santa Monica, where she was a longtime supporter of environmental causes and charities, including the Children's Burn Foundation, on whose council she served. The philanthropy was not performative. She had spent her adult life away from cameras, and the causes she supported were the ones she believed in, not the ones that photographed well. She was, in the best sense, a private citizen who had once been famous, and who used what remained of that fame quietly.

One Cameo and the Anniversaries

Holdridge's only return to a film set came in 2000, when she had a cameo in The Flintstones in Viva Rock Vegas, a small part in a big, silly movie that let her be on camera one more time without pretending it was a comeback. She also appeared at Disneyland's fiftieth anniversary celebrations in 2005, and in documentary specials about Cary Grant in 2005 and about Barbara Hutton, her first mother-in-law, in 2006. These were not attempts to restart a career. They were the appearances of a woman who was proud of where she had been and who enjoyed, occasionally, going back. Mouseketeer reunions were, for Holdridge, less about nostalgia than about friendship, and she attended them when she could, greeting fans who had grown up watching her smile.

The anniversary appearances matter because they show what Holdridge's fame had become by her sixties: not a burden, but a membership. She was a Mouseketeer, and Mouseketeers take care of each other, show up for each other, and remember each other. When Doreen Tracey announced Holdridge's death, she was not speaking as a publicist. She was speaking as a sister from the Red Team, and that is the kind of loyalty the Mouseketeer years created.

Lung Cancer and Death

Holdridge was diagnosed with lung cancer in 2007, and she fought it for two years, privately, as she had lived most of her adult life. She died on January 6, 2009, at her home in Santa Monica, at the age of 64, and the news was announced by Tracey on behalf of the family. The obituaries that followed remembered her as a Mouseketeer first and as Julie Foster second, and they remembered the Million Dollar Smile, which is how she would have wanted to be remembered. She was survived by the Mouseketeer family she had never really left.

There is a temptation, with a life like Holdridge's, to treat the retirement at twenty as a tragedy, a talent wasted. It was not. She chose it, she lived with it for forty-five years, and she never expressed regret for it in public. She had been a child performer, a television star, a racing driver's wife, a widow, a philanthropist, and a Mouseketeer, and she had been each of those things on her own terms. The smile in the photographs is not the smile of someone who was trapped. It is the smile of someone who knew what she wanted.

Where Cheryl Holdridge Is Now

Cheryl Holdridge is not with us anymore, and that is the honest answer to what happened to her. She died in 2009, at 64, after a life that took her from New Orleans to Los Angeles, from the Mouseketeer Red Team to Wally Cleaver's girlfriend, from a racing driver's wife to a Santa Monica philanthropist, and from a child star to a private citizen who chose, at twenty, to stop. She is remembered by Mouseketeer fans, by Leave It to Beaver fans, and by the charities she supported, and she is remembered, above all, for a smile that really was worth a million dollars.

What she leaves behind is a small, perfect filmography and a large, quiet example. Not every child star needs to keep performing to matter. Some of them perform brilliantly for a decade, marry, live, give, and die at home, surrounded by the people who loved them. Cheryl Holdridge did that, and the Million Dollar Smile, in the photographs that survive her, has not dimmed at all.

Frequently asked questions

What happened to Cheryl Holdridge?

Cheryl Holdridge died January 6, 2009, at 64, at her Santa Monica home after a two-year battle with lung cancer. She had retired from acting in 1964 at 20 to marry Lance Reventlow.

Who was Cheryl Holdridge on The Mickey Mouse Club?

She was a Mouseketeer from 1956 to 1959 on the Red Team, known as the Mouseketeer with the Million Dollar Smile.

Who did Cheryl Holdridge play on Leave It to Beaver?

She played Julie Foster, Wally Cleaver's girlfriend, in a recurring role, after first appearing as Gloria Cusick in two 1959 episodes. She reprised Julie in 1985 and 1987.

Why did Cheryl Holdridge retire from acting?

At 20, in 1964, she retired to marry race car driver Lance Reventlow, saying that was what you did then: you married and stayed home.

Did Cheryl Holdridge divorce Lance Reventlow?

No. Their marriage ended with Reventlow's death in a small-plane crash on July 24, 1972. Claims of a divorce are false.

Did Cheryl Holdridge have children?

No. Reliable obituary reporting says she had no children. Low-tier biographies claiming otherwise are false.

Who was Cheryl Holdridge's second husband?

Manning J. Post, a West Coast Democratic fundraiser and adviser, whom she married in 1994. He died in 2000.

When did Cheryl Holdridge die?

January 6, 2009, at her home in Santa Monica, at 64, after a two-year battle with lung cancer. Her death was announced by fellow Mouseketeer Doreen Tracey.

Sources

  • EN WikipediaBiography, Mouseketeer years, Leave It to Beaver, marriages, death 2009
  • Associated Press via All About JazzDeath January 6, 2009, Santa Monica, two-year lung cancer battle, announced by Doreen Tracey
  • Disney WikiMouseketeer serials, Grant High School 1961, Australia tour 1960, Flintstones cameo 2000